Haitong International 2023 Hong Kong Open Windsurfing Championships

Official Notice Board

Hearing Decisions

No. Type Race Initiator Respondent(s) Decision
15. Protest and Request for Redress 10 iQFOiL - Youth - HKG HKG32 - HKGWC7 iQFOiL - Youth Boys - HKG HKG35 - HKGAS6
Rules: RRS 63.1
The international jury allows the protest to be withdrawn. 

14. Protest and Request for Redress 10 iQFOiL - Youth - HKG HKG38 - HKGWC10 iQFOiL - Youth - HKG HKG32 - HKGWC7
Rules: RRS 11, 14, 16.1, 43.1(a), 43.1(b), 61.1(a)(1), B2.17, B5.62.1(b).
Protest upheld.
HKG 32 is exonerated by RRS 43.1(a) for her breach of RRS 16.1 and B2.17. 
HKG 38 is exonerated by RRS 43.1(b) for her breach of RRS 11. 
 
Redress is given to HKG 38. HKG 38 is to be scored in race 10 points equal to the average, rounded to the nearest tenth of a point (0.05 to be rounded upward), of her points in all slalom races sailed on 3 November 2023, except race 10. No other board's score shall change. 
13. Protest and Request for Redress 12 iQFOiL - Youth - HKG HKG32 - HKGWC7 iQFOiL - Youth - KOR KOR327 - KORHB2
Heard With Protest(s): 12
Rules: RRS 61.2(b), 62.2, 63.2, 63.3 (b), 63.5.
The protest and request of redress is invalid, the hearing is closed under RRS 63.5. 
12. Protest and Request for Redress 12 iQFOiL - Youth - KOR KOR327 - KORHB2 iQFOiL - Youth - HKG HKG32 - HKGWC7
Heard With: 13
11. Protest 8 iQFOiL - Youth - HKG HKG26 - HKGTY4 iQFOiL - Youth - THA THA10
Rules: RRS 63.1
 The international jury allows the protest to be withdrawn. 

10. Protest 3 FOIL - Junior Girls - HKG HKG13 - Gatsby Wong Foil - Junior girl - HKG 24 - Bernice Cheung
Rules: RRS 63.1
 The international jury allows the protest to be withdrawn. 

09. Protest 1 FOIL - Minim Girls - HKG64 FOIL - Minim Girls - HKG HKG69
Rules: RRS 63.1
 The international jury allows the protest to be withdrawn. 

08. Protest 1 FOIL - Minim Boys - HKG HKG85 FOIL - Minim Boys - HKG HKG62
Rules: RRS 63.1
 The international jury allows the protest to be withdrawn. 

07. Protest All FOIL - Minim Boys - HKG HKG84 FOIL - Minim Boys - HKG HKG86
Rules: RRS 63.1
 The international jury allows the protest to be withdrawn. 

06. Protest 4 FOIL - Minim Boys - HKG HKG85 FOIL - Minim Boys - HKG HKG86
Rules: RRS 63.1
 The international jury allows the protest to be withdrawn. 

05. Request for Redress Race number 4 FOIL - Minim Boys - HKG HKG72
Heard With: 04
04. Protest Race 4 FOIL - Minim Boys - HKG HKG72 FOIL - Minim Boys - HKG HKG51 - HKGCW8
Heard With Protest(s): 03, 05
Rules: RRS 11, 14, 16.1, 43.1(a), 43.1(b), 43.1(c), 63.2, 64.2(a), B2.17, B5.62.1(b).
The protest is upheld. Since HKG 51 took an applicable penalty, she is not further penalized under RRS 64.2(a). 
Redress is given to HKG 72 and HKG 65. HKG 72 is to be scored in race 4 points equal to the average, rounded to the nearest tenth of a point (0.05 to be rounded upward), of her points in all slalom races sailed on 1 November 2023, except race 4. HKG 72's score shall not be worse than her finishing position in the race (20th). 
HKG 65 is to be scored in race 4 points equal to the average, rounded to the nearest tenth of a point (0.05 to be rounded upward), of her points in all slalom races sailed on 1 November 2023, except race 4. HKG 65's score shall not be worse than her finishing position in the race (16th). 
No other board's score shall change. 
03. Protest 4 FOIL - Minim Boys - HKG HKG65 - HKGCC16 Foil - Minimum boys - HKG HKG72
Heard With: 04
02. Protest Race 2 FOIL - Minim Boys - HKG HKG67 FOIL - Minim Boys - HKG HKG5790
FOIL - Minim Boys - HKG HKG5791
Rules: RRS 28.1, 64.2(a), N 1.4(b).
 The protest is upheld. Since HKG 5790 and HKG 5791 took an applicable penalty, they are not further penalized under RRS 64.2(a). 
01. Protest and Request for Redress 1 iQFOiL - Youth Boys - HKG HKG37 - HKGAK1 iQFOiL - Youth Boys - HKG HKG30
Rules: RRS 10, 64.2(a), B5.62.1(b), N1.4(b).
Redress is given to HKG 37. HKG 37 is to be scored in race 1 points equal to the average, rounded to the nearest tenth of a point (0.05 to be rounded upward), of her points in all course races sailed on 1 November 2023, except race 1. HKG 37's score shall not be worse than her finishing position in the race (2nd). 
No other board's score shall change.