Forum: The Racing Rules of Sailing

Starting and the string rule

Dan Falcon
Nationality: United States
Given the following:
  • Wind is light.
  • Starting line is basically East-West, proper course is basically NNW.
  • Current is strong, going from NNE to SSW, pushing boats away from the starting line.
With this situation...
  • Boat B crosses the starting line after the gun.
  • The wind dies basically as the race starts.
  • Boat B drifts back across the starting line and winds up well west of the line before anchoring.
  • The wind picks up.
  • Boat B sails straight N to the windward mark, which is shorter than returning to the starting line.
So...
  • Under the string rule, Boat B has not sailed the course, because Boat B un-crossed the starting line. Under the definition of Sail the Course, a string pulled taut for Boat B would not pass between the two ends of the starting line.
Right?
Created: 23-Apr-25 18:29

Comments

Kett Cummins
Nationality: United States
1
The RC should abandon and restart when the wind fills in.  Not everything is the competitors' responsibility and not every contingency is covered by the RRS.
Created: 23-Apr-25 19:29
Carrick Woodfield
Nationality: Canada
Certifications:
  • Club Race Officer
  • Judge In Training
0
Yes Dan to put it simply you are correct, the boat did not meet the definition of Sail the Course.  Out of interest how long after the start did the wind come in, was it sufficient and did it stay long enough for competitors to finish?
Created: 23-Apr-25 21:30
Robert Stewart
Nationality: Canada
Certifications:
  • International Judge
0
Review World Sailing Case 90 as it is similar to scenario proposed.
Created: 23-Apr-26 00:30
Dan Falcon
Nationality: United States
1
Thanks all!

The situation was just an unusual variation on the seasonal pattern. Usually, the wind is light from the east, then, about an hour before start, it dies down then swings to be fresh from north and strengthens from there. Most days, anyway. This day it just happened to die, start to freshen, then die again, then it filled in about an hour later than usual.

So, Kett, it wasn't the best day for the RC, but they weren't nuts. It was reasonable to expect it to improve at pretty much any moment. They did delay the subsequent starts. But with three or so starts already away, some of which made pretty good distance before it died, abandoning would have been tough.

Carrick, we were on the anchor for about 10 minutes, maybe 20 max? Five minutes feels like a day. And then the wind showed up as usual and was fine for the rest of the day.

Thanks again!
Created: 23-Apr-26 17:51
Dan Falcon
Nationality: United States
0
Thanks Robert, that is exactly the same case, just with the side of the course with the new wind reversed! ;)
Created: 23-Apr-28 00:47
[You must be signed in to add a comment]
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn more