I am a J.I.T. as well as a prospective Club Race Officer. There is no "In-Training" category for Race Officers. I have the opportunity to be on both the Race Committee and the Protest Committee for an up-coming regatta (if it happens). I am also new to this forum so if this is the wrong place to just ask a question I understand. Is there any reason to not participate as both? There will be no on-the-water judging. Thank you.
US Sailing Judges Program
That said, you usually do not want to be on both as the RC may be involved in a protest or R4R. So, if you are short handed, you could be on the panel but you should have a backup to replace you in the event a hearing involves the RC.
I have been in the position that a competitors perception was that I had a conflict of interest when I was chairman of the protest committee but helped on a safety issue in the Philippines Hobie Challenge. (I was an IJ at the time but have subsequently retired for health reasons). It was a very difficult and contentious redresss request from a very aggressive competitor.
I withdrew from the protest committee although the committee members did ask for some rules clarifications during the hearing. The remaining members, none of whom were judges, went through the protest process and took the decisions in my absence. The competitor didn't like it but had to accept the protest committee decision and didn't have grounds to go to appeal.
- you only have a relatively minor role on the race committee. Not judging the start or finish. I have often helped out in this way and volunteered to do the time keeping
- declare a conflict of interest for any request for redress concerning an improper action or omission of the race committee
- accept with good grace any objection by a party to the hearing and stand down
In many cases if you declare a conflict of interest the parties will accept that you continue on the panel. If they agree they cannot object later.
Gordon
I dont recommend doing so unless you have a good reason for wanting to do both (In my case, this was wanting to learn from multiple IROs on the Race Committee while also needing hearings for Club Judge certification). Race Committee tends to start early in the morning, while Protests can run late into the evening, so you may be subjected to very long days (unless your role on RC is only as scorer).
As mentioned by others, conflict of interest can be an issue, though I have found most competitors won't care for a boat v boat protest. Plan on sitting out for most requests for redress (at least those 'against' race committee).
In summary, communication between all involved parties is key here, and know what you are getting into.
With that said, if you have an opportunity to judge take it. The hardest part of moving from Judge in training to judge at any level is getting your Protests in within the time frame. At local club events there are just not that many protest that actually make it to the room. So do it when the opportunity presents itself.
For Ang: I actually prefer "Con" but Conal will do.
Thanks everyone for taking the time to discuss a topic that seems to be solved with common sense without the need for more rules. I am sure I will have a lot of questions in the future.