Rules | ||
---|---|---|
Racing Rules of Sailing for 2013-2016; Version 6 | December 2015 | |
Racing Rules of Sailing for 2017-2020 | August 2017 | |
Racing Rules of Sailing for 2021-2024 | December 2020 | |
Prescriptions | ||
Australia | July 2017 | |
Canada | November 2019 | |
Great Britain - RYA has declined to grant a license for prescriptions and cases. | November 2019 | |
New Zealand | July 2017 | |
United States | February 2017 | |
Cases | ||
World Sailing Cases | February 2022 | |
World Sailing Q&As | March 2022 | |
Match Race Calls | January 2020 | |
Match Race Rapid Response Calls | October 2018 | |
Team Race Calls | December 2018 | |
Team Race Rapid Response Calls | February 2016 | |
CAN Cases | October 2017 | |
RYA Cases | November 2019 | |
US Appeals | November 2019 | |
Manuals | ||
World Sailing Judges Manual | December 2019 |
Obstruction is defined, but continuing is not. Therefore continuing is used in the sense ordinarily understood in nautical terms of general use.
So a continuing obstruction is an ongoing obstruction or obstruction without a break in continuity.
The island in your picture would appear to be a continuing obstruction, the boats are not.
How do you actually 'apply' that word? What is 'ordinary use' to you?
Here's how I use the term 'Continuous', when I think of obstructions.
As mentioned, in an ordinary sense, 'a continuous obstruction' is one which doesn't come to an end when a non-continuous obstruction would do.
Well, the definition of 'Obstruction' says that it is an object which from one hull length, requires a substantial course change to avoid it.
After making that substantial course change and avoiding the obstruction (say, a position abeam), can the boat turn back and resume her original track on the other side of the obstruction??
If the answer is no, then then to me it was a 'Continuing Obstruction'.
What do you think?
This is a start line.
Less than 60 sec to start.
a) The dock is an Continuing Obstruction ?
b) Around the dock, applies rule 18 or 19 ?
THANKS A LOT !!!
THANKS !!!!!
May i think "Continuing" in funcion with time ?
If you pass the pier in this direction, the obstruction lasts just few seconds.....so the pier is only an OBSTRUCTION and is a Mark, so aplies Seccion C, .....rule 18 is on, and 19 is OUT because 19.1(a)
By the direction of the flag you drawn, i presumed a start downwind; boat on port tack, along the pier: continuous
Boat on starboard, as per your flag and arrow: ,if you consider the tip of the pier as mark, guess 18 might be ok, by the book; though it's quite difficult to know for anybody, boats included, if there were a 18.2 or not, specially if boats were waiting for the start since some time.
Myself, being the tip of the pier possibly a mark, but just behind the tip, it's not, I would apply 19.
Reading (actually: dissecting) the definition of "mark":
Mark An object the sailing instructions require a boat to leave on a specified side, and a race committee vessel surrounded by navigable water from which the starting or finishing line extends.
If it's required, by the definition, that the sailing instruction have to specify which side to leave the object, in order to consider it a "mark", i believe that such object should have the physical possibility to be left also on the other side.
A pier: no option. That's why I would still consider the pier an obstacle only.
Veeeeery much my opinion.
And after this upcoming sleepless night, who knows...
Where we sail, we may have whales.
And you can see sleepping ones and others that swim with you
The whale has R.O.W.
Hahahahha