Note: This forum is not affiliated with World Sailing and comments on this forum do not represent an official interpretation of the rules, definitions, cases or regulations. The only official interpretations are those of World Sailing.
Sean, the issue is often covered in the class rules. Here is a example from the IMOCA class rules;
C.2 SERVO POWER AND MANOEUVRING (a) RRS Rule 52 is replaced as follows : « The boat’s standing rigging, running rigging, sails, spars, foils or daggerboards shall be adjusted and operated only with the power provided by the crew. Only the keel, the rudders and the filling, transferring and emptying of the ballast tanks may be controlled and adjusted by power provided from other sources. »
When I saw the initial question above, it immediately made me wonder what people would respond... but I am still confused after reading the responses so far. Let me explain: most autopilots have many inputs (wind direction being the most relevant to sailboats) only one control: powered rudder movement. R52 says that power to adjust and operate the rudder can come from other source different from crew. So I think the initial question must be decomposed into the "auto" and "pilot" parts:
Does R52 allow for electric/pneumatic rudder adjustment? --> I say yes, it clearly allows. This is the "pilot" of the system - a system can be used to adjust/pilot the rudder.
Does R52 allow for an automated feedback loop to decide the correct rudder position automatically? --> This is the "auto" part of the system, the part that autonomously decides where the rudder should be set at any given time. - R52 does not talk about this at all!
So I think question #2 remains, and I think it was what Sean Hanley was initially asking about, right? I am eager to hear opinions now...
C.2 SERVO POWER AND MANOEUVRING
(a) RRS Rule 52 is replaced as follows :
« The boat’s standing rigging, running rigging, sails, spars, foils or daggerboards shall be adjusted and operated only with the power provided by the crew. Only the keel, the rudders and the filling, transferring and emptying of the ballast tanks may be controlled and adjusted by power provided from other sources. »
Hope this helps.
So I think question #2 remains, and I think it was what Sean Hanley was initially asking about, right?
I am eager to hear opinions now...
Thank you.
But would it apply to windvane self-steering? I kind of think not...
Does anyone know how ORCi handles it?
Is the power for wind vane steering provided by the crew?
I don't think so.
Rule 52 doesn't say power can't be provided mechanically, it says power shall be provided by the crew.