I'm a fan of Appendix U and I also generously use Starting Penalties to control General Recalls. Since Appendix U does not require flags, but 30.1, 30.2, 30.3, and 30.4 do, how does the Race Management community feel about using SI changes to not only enact Appendix U, but also require the display of starting penalty flags or P flags from 2 to 1 minute before the start?
You can see mods as you suggest in the upcoming NOODs SI‘s.
I'm not part of the AYC-RC, but I have competed my J/105 in several starts where the SI-modified Appx U has been used for all classes, the vast majority being keelboats >20 feet.
It did take me a bit to get used to on the receiving end, but AYC-RC is doing a good job communicating via VHF what's happening .. and so I only once crossed the line 2 min's ahead of time :-)
Reference is to a US Sailing national prescription (Appendix U) for a 3 minute sound-based starting sequence commonly used in high school dinghy racing.
Signals identifiable by number and duration indicate time remaining at 3, 2:30, 2, 1:30, 1, 0:30, :20, :10, :05,4,3,2,1, start.
Visual signals are optional, but times are taken from the start of the audible signal.
Thanks!